Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Katalin Ferber's avatar

This is the best analytical framework and in depth study on the current international (global) situation. The author style and logic remind me of Peter Gowan, whom we have lost painfully early... Excellent, and honestly, I do not care whether it is "grim" or "hopeless", because knowing thus facing to the current stage of affairs -according to my view-far better, than anything else. This analysis equips me to think more, read more and if possible, write more. Thank you indeed. K Ferber (economic historian).

Maria Mulligan's avatar

OMG…..I hadn’t looked at the world through those lens’s (which are pretty grim) but what you’ve suggested makes a lot of sense and yours is a really well thought out essay.

Greed is the issue at the heart of capitalism. More always seems to want more, and more is celebrated. I get what you’re saying that adjustments would only have slowed the decline but I’m not fully convinced that capitalism was always a fait accompli. We (the people)didn’t put the effort into checking out who we supported, we didn’t take the time to educate ourselves on the options for governance, we didn’t stop to ask if we really needed a purchase (wanton consumerism), we didn’t challenge governing parties, we don’t take the time to analyse what we are being fed by media (even now when it’s so easy to fact check things). We hold a lot of responsibility.

Maybe simple local Saturday get togethers for teenagers and young adults regarding these issues would be worth thinking about - that group love talking politics and are genuine in their wish to learn more about options and different systems. I’d like to see the voting age lowered to 16 years. In my more frustrated moments I’d like to have some sort of test you need to pass before you can cast your vote (just to indicate you have some grasp on politics and the political system).

Capitalism is a failed system and the imperialism that accompanied it for most of its journey was hideous. In more recent decades we could have moved to more socialist models but greed and complacency seem to have played their part - yes other powerful forces were there but they fed off our inaction and became stronger because of it. We regular people have to take responsibility for the mess we’ve created. I still believe (maybe naively) that something better will emerge. But, I also believe it will involve living differently, more modestly, putting in effort into our politics, turning towards local community again, challenging media bs narratives, taking time to teach our children critical thinking skills and facilitating discussions with them to explore values and ethics. I believe we still have power but do we want the fight?

Thank you for a very thought provoking essay.

3 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?